Solemn judgment cannot negate chainable monster effects. Actually, it can t negate all type of monster effects. This swiss army knife of negation stops pretty much anything short of monster effects. When a monsters would be summoned, or when a spelltrap card, or monster. Do you also negate a monsters flip effect if you negate. Solemn judgment, thunder king raioh, black horn of heaven, evolzar laggia can t negate summons of monsters like gorz, tragoedia, chaos hunter, battle fader, because their effects that special summon itself is a trigger effect. Another solemn dont worry, this one negates the solemns solemn trespassing johnhabib25 archived. Player as xsaber souza with the effect to destroy a battling monster in damage step active attacks player bs ally of justice catastor. If solemn strike is used to negate the effect of a pendulum monster that has activated and gone to the extra deck eccentrick, ariadne, helix, carrier does that monster go to grave or stay in the extra deck.
You can only activate 1 spellbook of secrets per turn. Negate the summon of a monster or the activation of a spell card, trap card, or effect monsters effect that includes an effect that special summons a monsters, and destroy that card. When a monster would be summoned, or a spelltrap card is activated. If you negate a monster s flip summon, then the flip effect will never even activate in the first place, meaning theres no need to negate it. When a monster s would be special summoned, or a monster effect is activated. You can send 1 other faceup altergeist card you control to the gy. In this situation, if i activate a set miraculous descent, can my opponent chain solemn judgment to negate the activation and destroy it. I want to know with cards solemn judgment can t negate. So ultimate providence will stop that kind of monster from activating its effect once but wont be able to destroy it.
Special summon it as a normal spell card, it can only be activated during your main phase 1 or main phase 2. If your opponent controls a monster that was special summoned from the extra. Here is a list of cards that will negate your opponents monster effects one way or another. So those kind of monsters can just use their negated effect.
In essence, which cards can solemn judgment, or thunder king raioh negate. Same reason raioh cannot negate a special summon through monster reborn. Can solemn judgment stop obelisk the effect version answers. However, if player b used royal oppression on ara, then player a could not activate duality. It has the power to stop a monster effect or trap card that negates the summon of a monster. Therefore, it can t negate a special summon that is a result of a monster effect.
No where on solemn judgement does it say it can negate monster effects. When a monsters would be summoned, or a spelltrap card is activated. I saw in the rulings for solemn judgment that it cant negate a special summon that is from a monster effect. Grand horn of heaven and black horn of heaven are amazing i think solemn scolding is the only counter trap that negate the summon. It cannot negate the effect of a card which special summons a monster. Another solemn dont worry, this one negates the solemns. Monsters like thunder king raioh, that can negate the special summon of a. Pay half your life points, negate the summon or activation, and if you do, destroy that card. Dont be afraid to read back on this article or bookmark it any time you need to explain inherent summons to newer players. The effects of spells and traps that activate after their initial activations are safe from scolding. Can negate extra normal summons gained through cards like double summon. Oppression negates only the effect of ara whereas solemn negates the activation of ara.
Sure, both can negate monster reborn, but for very different reasons. Gorz the emissary of darkness is being special summoned by a monster effect. I hope konami release solemn warning, solemn judgment and solemn strike. The effect the activation and effects of altergeist cards activated on your field cannot be negated. Card activation vs effect activation duelist codex. If it relies on an outside factor to perform the special summon, then it is a summon that is started by a chain. Its true that solemn judgement can negate card in yu gi. It is therefore not yet a tribute summoned monster, and receives no protection from march of the monarchs. Moreover, once gorz resolves, the game state is now closed, and solemn judgment can no longer use its effect to negate the special summon of the gorz. However, if solemn judgment is used to negate a flip summon, then the flip effect of the monster is not triggered, as the flip summon was negated, and thus considered to have not happened. Solemn strike to negate the summon, will player a be able to activate the effect of. Its true that solemn judgement can negate card in yu gi oh. Its also powerless against continuous effects, as well as any card whose summon or activation can t be responded to.
Solemn judgment cannot negate something which has yet to be summoned. Add 1 spellbook card from your deck to your hand, except spellbook of secrets. Solemn warning can be activated to negate the special summon of. Secondly, while solemn judgement negates everything, warning only negates monster summons. Another solemn dont worry, this one negates the solemns solemn trespassing johnhabib25. Solemn judgment cannot negate the effect of a monster. Solemn warning stops your opponent from summoning, no matter what way they try to do so. As well as negating any type of summon possible, solemn warning can negate the effects of cards that special summon monsters, stopping. The latter is a rarer sight but players have been running starlight road in a bid to escape board wipes and massive backrow destruction. The most common judge calls i receive are can i negate this special. These counter traps would be great than stupid solemn scolding. So with solemn warning, the card effect states that by paying 2000 life points, you can negate a summon or special summon or negate the effect of a card that special summons a monster and destroy it. Can umastrix use its third effect again to set itself facedown this turn.
Solemn warning can stop any effect that summons a monster, whether it be a spell, trap, or monster effect, or just any summon like a normal or flip summon. Whereas, strike would only stop the monster effect. It can stop any kind of summon, even flip summons and special summons. Solemn warning does not have such a restriction as its effect includes the ability to negate monster effects as well. Negate an activation of a spell trap card normal summon flip summon special. I believe in this situation that player a can activate pot of duality bc the activation of advanced ritual art was negated by solemn. A stupid questions about solemn judgment forumotion. You will receive the 1st edition version of this card. Only solemn warning can stop these summons, because solemn warning can negate any spelltrap monster effects that include the special summon of a monster as well as inherent summons. Smashing horn is the latest counter trap that can foil your opponents plays. By paying half of your life points, you can negate the summon of a monster, or the activation of a spelltrap and destroy it. With solemn strike, the card effect states that by paying 1500 life points, you can negate a special summon or negate any monster effect and destroy that monster. The only things you can t negate with a solemn judgment are monster effects and nomal sets.
Negate that special summon, and if you do destroy it. Effective difference between solemn strike and solemn. Since solemn judgement negates the activation of cards, would i be able to activate my other copy, or does it not work that way. Solemn warning is a counter trap card that can negate the summon of a monster at the cost of 2000 life points. Solemn judgment can negate summons that dont use the chain, by waiting until the monster is placed on the field, then negating the summon before it counts as being successful. This would mean its passive effect such as cannot be destroyed by card effects wont be negated. It says it can negate the activation of a spell card or trap card or monster effect that includes an effect of special summoning a monster s. Dark world monsters are special summoned to the field by their own effect, and if you try solemn judgment, it would be like trying to stop a monster effect, which solemn judgment can. A counter trap that negates monster effs and special summons, get outta town this card alone can stop ya zings from spamming the board with their effs from the grave. But if in case you summon a monarch,or jinzo and others,and the opponent activated solemn judgement,the monster s effect isnt activated,because in this case,the monster. Gladiator beast conflict chariot, stardust dragon, pollinessis, the forbidden chalice, the ultimate one is solemn judgment, it wont negate outcomes inspite of the undeniable fact that this is going to negate the summoning of the monster till. This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies. Cannot negate a normal summon through ultimate offering. This is the main reason people dont understand why warning can negate gorz but not judgment, when in their minds both warning and judgment can negate monster reborn.
Lets compare judgment to each of the other solemn cards. I assume warning can be activated in response to the summon. Monster reborn is a normal spell card with the following effect. Well, monster summons and any other card or effect of a monster that special summon a monster s, and. Judgment and strike are very different in function. This means that solemn warning and solemn judgment can both be pulverized by smashing horn while theyre trying to negate a monster s summon. Solemn judgment can negate polymerisation simply because it is a spell card. One immediately negative is the fact that you wouldnt necessarily be able to play this card whenever you wanted or needed to, as you can with judgement. Note the activation timing of solemn judgement emphasis mine. Solemn notice trap counter activate 1 of the following effects by paying 1500 lp. Many cards can only negate monsters, spells, or traps, making those. Solemn warning takes care of starlight road, and there is really no way around it.
I will not answer new questions in the article comments. If you understand this rule, you should be quite confident in your general yugioh abilities. I hope if you read this, it at least helped you at least a little bit. I think your talking about jinzo monster negates traps or thought ruler archfiend synchro monster negates spell or traps that target a psychic type by paying life points or divine wrath counter trap discard a card. Gladiator beast war chariotskill drain solemn judgment divine wrathancient gear beastby order of the emperordark illusionlight imprisoning mirrorshadow imprisoning mirrorpulling the rug. But i see the judges at my local tournament do this all the time. It does not say that an effect of special summoning a monster s has to be activated, but merely included in the cards effects upon activation. Includes an effect means that its possible for the activated spelltrap card, or monster effect, to special summon something when it initially resolves. Negate the activation of a spell card trap card normal summon flip summon special summon and destroy the spell card, trap card, or summoned monster.